Clay Neighborhood Forecasts

Explore neighborhood-level home price forecasts and trends across Clay. See which areas have the strongest upside and lowest housing market risk.

Forecasts as of March 2026

Clay Live Forecast Map

Open Full Map ↗

Neighborhoods Covered

Highest 5yr Upside

+17.9%

Typical Value Range

$204K to $429K

Browse Markets

Sort:

1Middleburg-Clay Hill · Middleburg · Tr.030209

Value$262K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+17.9%

vs. Clay

+10%

2Keystone Heights · 32656 · Tr.031109

Value$124K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+14.2%

vs. Clay

+6%

3Middleburg-Clay Hill · Jacksonville · Tr.030105

Value$170K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+13.7%

vs. Clay

+5%

4Keystone Heights · Starke

Value$433K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+13.5%

vs. Clay

+5%

5Bellair-Meadowbrook Terrace · Orange Park · Tr.030400

Value$221K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+13.5%

vs. Clay

+5%

6Middleburg-Clay Hill · Jacksonville · Tr.030104

Value$204K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+13.2%

vs. Clay

+5%

7Orange Park · 32073 · Tr.030303

Value$270K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+12.7%

vs. Clay

+4%

8Orange Park · 32073 · Tr.030306

Value$422K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+12.4%

vs. Clay

+4%

9Green Cove Springs · 32043 · Tr.031500

Value$300K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+12.4%

vs. Clay

+4%

10Penney Farms · Green Cove Springs · Tr.031202

Value$326K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+12.2%

vs. Clay

+4%

11Keystone Heights · 32656 · Tr.031104

Value$258K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+12.0%

vs. Clay

+4%

12Middleburg-Clay Hill · Middleburg · Tr.030103

Value$229K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+11.6%

vs. Clay

+3%

13Oakleaf Plantation · Orange Park · Tr.030207

Value$312K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+11.2%

vs. Clay

+3%

14Orange Park · 32073 · Tr.030500

Value$282K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+10.1%

vs. Clay

+2%

15Keystone Heights · 32656 · Tr.031108

Value$292K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+9.9%

vs. Clay

+2%

16Green Cove Springs · 32043 · Tr.031302

Value$470K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+9.7%

vs. Clay

+1%

17Lakeside · Orange Park · Tr.030906

Value$194K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+9.7%

vs. Clay

+1%

18Lakeside · Orange Park

Value$330K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+9.2%

vs. Clay

+1%

19Middleburg

Value$214K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+8.3%

vs. Clay

–

20Orange Park · Fleming Island

Value$494K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+8.1%

vs. Clay

–

21Fleming Island · 32003 · Tr.030701

Value$392K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+8.1%

vs. Clay

–

22Fleming Island · 32003 · Tr.030705

Value$462K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+8.0%

vs. Clay

–

23Orange Park · 32073 · Tr.030600

Value$396K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+8.0%

vs. Clay

–

24Middleburg-Clay Hill · Middleburg · Tr.030204

Value$355K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+7.1%

vs. Clay

-1%

25Middleburg-Clay Hill · Middleburg · Tr.030210

Value$351K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+7.1%

vs. Clay

-1%

26Fleming Island · 32003 · Tr.030707

Value$387K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+7.0%

vs. Clay

-1%

27Keystone Heights · Green Cove Springs

Value$236K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+6.9%

vs. Clay

-1%

28Middleburg-Clay Hill · Orange Park

Value$378K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+6.9%

vs. Clay

-1%

29Oakleaf Plantation · Orange Park · Tr.030208

Value$265K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+6.6%

vs. Clay

-2%

30Lakeside · Orange Park · Tr.030904

Value$317K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+6.6%

vs. Clay

-2%

31Fleming Island · 32003 · Tr.030706

Value$368K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+6.5%

vs. Clay

-2%

32Penney Farms · Green Cove Springs · Tr.031201

Value$353K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+6.0%

vs. Clay

-2%

33Green Cove Springs · 32043 · Tr.031301

Value$332K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+6.0%

vs. Clay

-2%

34Green Cove Springs · 32043 · Tr.031303

Value$429K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+5.9%

vs. Clay

-2%

35Orange Park · Middleburg · Tr.030708

Value$274K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+5.6%

vs. Clay

-3%

36Keystone Heights · Middleburg

Value$332K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+4.8%

vs. Clay

-3%

37Bellair-Meadowbrook Terrace · Orange Park · Tr.030305

Value$222K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+4.7%

vs. Clay

-4%

38Lakeside · Orange Park · Tr.030903

Value$262K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+4.4%

vs. Clay

-4%

39Green Cove Springs · 32043 · Tr.031400

Value$199K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+4.3%

vs. Clay

-4%

40Bellair-Meadowbrook Terrace · Orange Park · Tr.030304

Value$230K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+4.2%

vs. Clay

-4%

41Middleburg-Clay Hill · Middleburg · Tr.030206

Value$362K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+4.2%

vs. Clay

-4%

42Penney Farms · Middleburg

Value$357K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+3.7%

vs. Clay

-4%

43Keystone Heights · 32656 · Tr.031110

Value$206K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+2.7%

vs. Clay

-6%

44Lakeside · Orange Park · Tr.030802

Value$260K

5yr Outlook vs 2026+1.4%

vs. Clay

-7%

45Orange Park · Middleburg · Tr.030905

Value$297K

5yr Outlook vs 2026-1.8%

vs. Clay

-10%

#	Neighborhood	Current Value	5yr Outlook vs 2026	vs. Clay
1	Middleburg-Clay Hill · Middleburg · Tr.030209	$262K	+17.9%	+10%
2	Keystone Heights · 32656 · Tr.031109	$124K	+14.2%	+6%
3	Middleburg-Clay Hill · Jacksonville · Tr.030105	$170K	+13.7%	+5%
4	Keystone Heights · Starke	$433K	+13.5%	+5%
5	Bellair-Meadowbrook Terrace · Orange Park · Tr.030400	$221K	+13.5%	+5%
6	Middleburg-Clay Hill · Jacksonville · Tr.030104	$204K	+13.2%	+5%
7	Orange Park · 32073 · Tr.030303	$270K	+12.7%	+4%
8	Orange Park · 32073 · Tr.030306	$422K	+12.4%	+4%
9	Green Cove Springs · 32043 · Tr.031500	$300K	+12.4%	+4%
10	Penney Farms · Green Cove Springs · Tr.031202	$326K	+12.2%	+4%
11	Keystone Heights · 32656 · Tr.031104	$258K	+12.0%	+4%
12	Middleburg-Clay Hill · Middleburg · Tr.030103	$229K	+11.6%	+3%
13	Oakleaf Plantation · Orange Park · Tr.030207	$312K	+11.2%	+3%
14	Orange Park · 32073 · Tr.030500	$282K	+10.1%	+2%
15	Keystone Heights · 32656 · Tr.031108	$292K	+9.9%	+2%
16	Green Cove Springs · 32043 · Tr.031302	$470K	+9.7%	+1%
17	Lakeside · Orange Park · Tr.030906	$194K	+9.7%	+1%
18	Lakeside · Orange Park	$330K	+9.2%	+1%
19	Middleburg	$214K	+8.3%	–
20	Orange Park · Fleming Island	$494K	+8.1%	–
21	Fleming Island · 32003 · Tr.030701	$392K	+8.1%	–
22	Fleming Island · 32003 · Tr.030705	$462K	+8.0%	–
23	Orange Park · 32073 · Tr.030600	$396K	+8.0%	–
24	Middleburg-Clay Hill · Middleburg · Tr.030204	$355K	+7.1%	-1%
25	Middleburg-Clay Hill · Middleburg · Tr.030210	$351K	+7.1%	-1%
26	Fleming Island · 32003 · Tr.030707	$387K	+7.0%	-1%
27	Keystone Heights · Green Cove Springs	$236K	+6.9%	-1%
28	Middleburg-Clay Hill · Orange Park	$378K	+6.9%	-1%
29	Oakleaf Plantation · Orange Park · Tr.030208	$265K	+6.6%	-2%
30	Lakeside · Orange Park · Tr.030904	$317K	+6.6%	-2%
31	Fleming Island · 32003 · Tr.030706	$368K	+6.5%	-2%
32	Penney Farms · Green Cove Springs · Tr.031201	$353K	+6.0%	-2%
33	Green Cove Springs · 32043 · Tr.031301	$332K	+6.0%	-2%
34	Green Cove Springs · 32043 · Tr.031303	$429K	+5.9%	-2%
35	Orange Park · Middleburg · Tr.030708	$274K	+5.6%	-3%
36	Keystone Heights · Middleburg	$332K	+4.8%	-3%
37	Bellair-Meadowbrook Terrace · Orange Park · Tr.030305	$222K	+4.7%	-4%
38	Lakeside · Orange Park · Tr.030903	$262K	+4.4%	-4%
39	Green Cove Springs · 32043 · Tr.031400	$199K	+4.3%	-4%
40	Bellair-Meadowbrook Terrace · Orange Park · Tr.030304	$230K	+4.2%	-4%
41	Middleburg-Clay Hill · Middleburg · Tr.030206	$362K	+4.2%	-4%
42	Penney Farms · Middleburg	$357K	+3.7%	-4%
43	Keystone Heights · 32656 · Tr.031110	$206K	+2.7%	-6%
44	Lakeside · Orange Park · Tr.030802	$260K	+1.4%	-7%
45	Orange Park · Middleburg · Tr.030905	$297K	-1.8%	-10%

Explore Homecastr.

Clay Neighborhood Forecasts

Browse Markets

Clay Neighborhood Forecasts

Explore Homecastr.

Clay Neighborhood Forecasts

Browse Markets

Browse Markets

Browse Markets